Selling· 4 min read ·

Does a Garden Suite Add Value When You Sell in Toronto?

Does a garden suite add value to your Toronto home? Here's who pays more for one, what the rules say about selling it, and when building first makes sense.

A modern garden suite in the backyard of a red-brick Toronto semi-detached house in autumn

Does a garden suite add value to your home when you sell? Yes, usually, but only to the right buyer, and rarely dollar for dollar with what you spent to build it. A finished, permitted suite widens your pool of buyers. A half-finished or unpermitted one can shrink it.

The short version: if you're building it to live in or rent out for years, go for it. If you're building it only to sell next spring, slow down and run the numbers first.

Backyard homes are no longer rare in Toronto. The city told CBC that 755 garden and laneway suites are under construction right now, with 627 permits closed. More of these will hit the resale market soon, and buyers will start comparing them.

Does a garden suite add value to your home?

A house with a legal second unit appeals to three groups:

  • Families with parents or adult kids who want everyone close but not under one roof.
  • Buyers who want help with the mortgage from a tenant out back.
  • Small investors who want two rents on one lot.

More buyers means stronger offers. That's where the value shows up.

But a suite also takes up the backyard. A young family who wants a big yard and a swing set may pay less, not more. An appraiser also needs similar nearby sales to back up the price, and those can be scarce. I'd never promise a seller that every dollar spent building comes back in the sale price.

Can you sever a garden suite and sell it separately?

No, and every Toronto homeowner should know this before they build. The City of Toronto's garden suite rules say a severance that puts the house and the suite on separate lots is not permitted.

You sell them together, as one property. So the suite is a feature of your house, not a second house you can cash out.

Should you build a garden suite before you sell?

For most sellers with a short timeline, no. Here's why:

  1. It takes time. Homeowners in that CBC story said permits and building took longer than expected.
  2. Financing can be tricky. Ottawa lets homeowners refinance up to 90% of the home's value after the suite is built, including the value the suite adds, on homes up to $2 million with up to a 30-year amortization. That works best if you plan to stay.
  3. Half-done hurts. A buyer won't pay for a suite that isn't finished and closed out with the city.

If your suite already exists, make it easy for a buyer. Have the permits, the final inspection and any rental history ready. If a tenant lives there, read up on selling a house with tenants in Ontario before you list.

And don't overprice because of it. Pricing a home with a unique feature well above the street is one of the mistakes to avoid when selling your home.

Frequently asked questions

Can I rent out a garden suite in Toronto?

Yes. A garden suite is a separate home on your lot, and you can rent it to a tenant, family member or anyone else. Once someone rents it, Ontario's tenant rules apply to that unit. That matters when you sell, because a buyer may want it empty or may want to keep the tenant and the rent.

Is a laneway suite the same as a garden suite?

They're close cousins. Both are a small home behind your house. The difference is location: a laneway suite sits on a lot that backs onto a public laneway, and a garden suite is for lots that don't. The City of Toronto has separate rules for each, so check which one applies to your property.

Do I pay development charges on a garden suite?

In Toronto, no, in most cases. The city exempts second, third and fourth units on a lot from development charges, as long as the lot has no more than four units. You still need a building permit and have to meet the zoning rules, so budget for design and permit costs.

If you're wondering what yours adds, or whether to build at all before you sell, book a call with me and we'll go through it together. You can also get a free home value estimate to start.

Thinking about selling?
See what your home is worth with this month's sales
Gary McGowan
Written by REALTOR® serving York Region and the GTA. I've trained thousands of Realtors across North America and beyond, and I host the RealtyChatter show. More about me. Ask Gary a questionBook a call

Get posts like this every Sunday

One email every Sunday morning. By subscribing you agree to get the Sunday Brief and occasional updates by email from Gary McGowan at RealtyChatter. Unsubscribe any time.